Showing posts with label Novel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Novel. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 30, 2012

#Day29 Peter Pan Part II


I assume that children's age is a phase for learning, remembering, knowing, and searching all experiences, pleasures and fantasies, although their attitude sometimes are considered illogical, aggressive, and having impolite manner than considered a normal gesture. As following quotation: 

“It is clear that the child in this state is not even prospectively a citizen who could be relied upon to do a hard day’s work. It is anarchic, sadistic, aggressive, self-involved and remorselessly pleasure seeking, under the sway of what Freud calls the pleasure principle; nor does it have any respect for differences of gender.” (Eagleton, 1983: 154) 

It cannot be denied that psychologically and physically, children cannot deal with daily hard work for their nature are brutal, disordered, or aggressive. They appropriately relate to playing, adventure, experience, imagination, and fantasy. In psychoanalytical theory, it is appropriate if Freud calls it as 'pleasure principle'. Hence, I perceive that children's age is a pleasure-oriented, an imagination oriented. They get a new experience and adventure from what they see and they can imitate it because children's age is also an imitation phase or it is called 'mimicry'. Their environment around them is not only imitated by them, but also it is a way for finding their identity. They saw and they know what it is. "The child, at an age when he is for a time, however short, outdone by the chimpanzee in instrumental intelligence, can nevertheless already recognize as such his own image in a mirror."(Lacan in Adams, 1992: 898) Children's age is a phase for brain development although its development is not as fast as chimpanzee's brain development, but they can know what they see/saw and remember it; include their own selves in a mirror. Furthermore, it is called in term 'mirror stage'. 
  
"This act, far from exhausting itself, as in the case of the monkey, once the image has been mastered and found empty, immediately rebounds in the case of the child in a series of gestures in which he experiences in play the relation between the movements assumed in the image and the reflected environment, and between this virtual complex and the reality it reduplicates – the child’s own body, and the persons and things around him” (Lacan in Adams, 1992: 898)

This stage is one way for children to communicate to themselves or their approach for knowing their circumstances and themselves. One image, which is reflected on their mind, can identify at any rate one gesture or attitude for child's mind work as similar as a mirror. In this period, they also recognize their own body and sexes. A boy can recognize that his body and sex is dissimilar from his mother. His close involvement with his mother even his mother's body abruptly has to be distinguished by that diversion. This period is one stage where boy recognize the diversion between his mother's body and him or called pre-oedipal stage. The child in pre-oedipal stage, as I mentioned above, is not only brutal and disordered, but also incestuous. The boy's relation with his mother's body instinctively directs his sexual desire for sexual desire union with his mother or furthermore Freud called it in term 'Oedipus complex'. However, this unconscious desire is not allowed to be for his father being as his rival. As this quotation argues: 
  
"The early ‘dyadic’ or two-term relationship between infant and mother, that is to say, has now opened up into a triangle consisting of child and both parents; and for the child, the parents of the same sex will come to figure as a rival in its affections for the parents of the opposite sex.” (Eagleton, 1983: 154)

The occurrence of father that has similar sex with him is considered a border for him hence the father has a function as 'symbolic order' that has rules and laws. Thus, his incestuous desire is being castrated and he regards this as a punishment for him by his incestuous desire. At last, this thing brings unconscious desire turning 'reality principle'. As I stated above, two polarizations in Barrie's Peter Pan novel - between child and mature, children and parents - are clearly depicted by this explanation using psychoanalysis approach.

Nevertheless, these polarizations finally convey that Wendy's disposition, a girl that is loved by Peter besides he regards her as a mother, is crucial for Peter Pan. Wendy is a fourteen-aged girl who flies with her two brothers following Peter, a boy whom she loves, to the Neverland. In the Neverland Wendy has a role as a mother for the lost boy whereas Peter becoming a father. This role-playing apparently is only a usual game for all children, but this game describes a little love intrigue between Wendy and Peter. However, Peter's desire and his passion to live with Wendy forever does not easily come true because Wendy is not like himself who never grown-up. Wendy is an ordinary girl who someday will grow up to be a woman and has her own life. 

The growth of Wendy becoming adult is the one border for Peter to live with her. Subsequently, it seems common if Peter forbids Wendy not to back to her nursery window as by mean that she returns to her home and life for becoming adult, and even, he regards Wendy's parents as his rival for his jealousy to her parents. This kind attitude is emerged from his love desire for Wendy or it is also caused by his passion to have a mother. 


*Part 3 is still being edited. :D

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

#Day28 Peter Pan: An analysis of Oedipus Complex (Part I)

“There is no death in imaginary, since the world’s continuing existence depends upon my life just as much as my life depends upon it; it is only by entering the symbolic order that we confront the truth that we can die, since the world’s existence does not in fact depend upon us.”
  -Terry Eagleton -

Imagination, fantasy, and dream properly relate to the children. No one can deny it. It is very possible for them to be in dreaming, to have fantasy and imagination. Peter Pan, a novel by J.M. Barrie, is one of children tale, which represents it. By this novel, Barrie wants to show imaginative world of children. As if, he wanted to allow children to have an imagination, which is irrational and illogical for adult as child opposite. At first when I read this novel, I regard it as a usual children tale; story of Wendy and her two brothers, John and Michael who fly to the Neverland, a land for particular children where all adventures is begun, with a boy who never grows up, Peter Pan through wide opened nursery room window. Nevertheless, it actually is not only children tale; it is a story about a boy who refuses to grow up and his oedipal passion. 

Peter Pan, a character of this story, who is regarded as a hero for children especially for all daughters influences them to have a courage to follow him going to Neverland although their parents forbid them (they think it was only an imagination) to not to do it, for Wendy, Michael, and John too. By their curiosity to know the existence of Neverland, Captain Hook, and Peter Pan itself, they cross all lines that are forbidden for them. Peter Pan is one of fantastic child because he cannot be mature and he can defeat Captain Hook, his enemy, so that he is suitable for regarding as a hero for children. Otherwise, children are afraid of Captain Hook, which is a tyranny and wicked pirate, and Peter Pan's enemy. 

From above recognition, I identify there are binary oppositions between children and parents, child and mature, or else obedience and authority. Peter Pan, Wendy and her two brothers are in child position, on the other hand, Parents and Captain Hook are in mature position. Among these polarizations, it correctly has a contradiction as hero-enemy opposition. It can be shown by the occurrence of Captain Hook as an enemy of Peter Pan, whereas he is as a hero and the occurrence of parents as a symbol of obedience and fear (by father's position that has rules and laws)



Part 2 coming soon...